HBP Chapter 20 re-read
Lord Voldemort’s Request
The low comedy with Professor Trelawney is very enjoyable and once again JKR makes sure that the reader remembers that she and Firenze are still at the school – a bit of business that could easily have been omitted except that it will be important in book seven. I thought it was funny when she tripped over her shawl.
Dumbledore’s attitude towards Divination interests me: causes “much more trouble than I could have foreseen”
“never having studied it myself.” A bit surprising that Dd, who is such a polymath, never studied the subject at all. His basic attitude seems to be that it’s all hokum, except when it isn’t.
As I reread the passage with Dd reprimanding Harry for his lame efforts to get the memory from Slughorn, I felt myself feeling a bit sorry for Harry. After all, Dumbledore is the adult, and Slughorn is his peer (and employee). Shouldn’t it really be Dd’s responsibility? Especially since it turns out later in the book that underneath it all Dd’s real motivation is that he thinks Harry is the person best situated to emotionally manipulate Slughorn into revealing the memory. Seeing an adult pressure a minor into manipulating another adult is not especially edifying … it underlines the depth of Dd’s desperation. Not something he would do unless the need was so great.
Tom Riddle’s visit to Dd’s office is a great scene and very thought provoking. I was struck by the similarity between Harry and Riddle, both more attached to Hogwarts than any other place, their home, where they’ve both been happiest. I’m not quite sure how, but it seems sure to me that The Final Confrontation will take place on the grounds of Hogwarts.
Wonder what special powers Holga Hufflepuff’s mug has. Presumably have something to do with the Hufflepuffian qualities of friendship, loyalty, and so on (what else?)
We know a bit more about the powers of Slytherin’s locket – whatever they are, they don’t include anything to do with giving the wearer health or financial well-being, since its last owners, the Gaunts, were notably unhealthy and poor. Perhaps it enhanced Merope’s powers of persuasion and enchantment…
Dd seems to have done an awful lot of tracking down witnesses and extracting memories. That seems to be par for the course for a high-class wizard – similarly, Voldemort spends much of his time running around creating false memories. This “memory modification” mode of high wizardry does leave some room for RAB at the end of the book to be someone who has been present all along, but skillfully hiding his presence. Harry doesn’t seem to be especially good at this stuff … he will have to rely on other techniques to get the crucial 411 about the Horcruxes in book seven.
The convo bwn Riddle and Dd is classic. Riddle’s “smeared” appearance is chilling. Dd is great at telling people off in a calm cool and collected manner. I wish I could have that presence of mind when I am in such situations!
At the end where Dd asks V’s purpose, we never get a straight answer.
The existence of a jinx against the DADA position is , in my mind, proven by Dd’s comment at the end of the chapter that the subsequent history of the DADA post “proves” that Riddle was after the DADA job.
So, yes, V wanted the DADA post … but why, exactly? His followers now seem to regard the discipline as a joke. Yes, it’s a good recruiting post, but is there anything more to it? Is it possible that the person who is teaching DADA at Hogwarts has any special magical privileges while within the bounds of Hogwarts?
Tags: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Law, YA by wfzimmerman
No Comments »