HBP Chapter 27 Re-read
The Lightning-Struck Tower
Again Harry demonstrates his “Accio” prowess with Accio Rosmerta’s brooms.
We learn later in the chapter that Rosmerta is under the Imperius Curse. I must say that this completely fooled me as it did Harry and Dd. She seemed genuinely distressed. Wonder exactly what Malfoy’s orders to her were?
Dd lets down the spells around Hogwarts so that they can enter at speed. We know from the preceding chapter that it is possible for a great wizard to make spells that can only be undone with great investment of time and effort. So Dd must have made the spells around Hogwarts of such a nature that he could always take them down quickly. Could he have provided better security with more cumbersome spells? Probably not, as he never even contemplated the possibility of the Vanishing Cabinet. Interesting nonetheless to see that even high wizards encounter the fundamental tension between security and usability. (see http://www.wfzimmerman.com/2005/09/oreillys-security-and-usability-first.html).
Why exactly did Dd immobilize Harry when he heard footsteps at the door? Why was that a priority over defending himself? Especially given that there were two brooms in the room and anyone entering would deduce immediately that another wizard must be present? Wouldn’t it have been better, tactically, to fight? Is Harry really that much of a loose cannon? This decision of Dd’s to immobilize Harry is not explained completely to my satisfaction … it leaves room to wonder if Dd for some reason set up the whole situation with himself apparently helpless.
The scene between Dd and Malfoy is one of the best things in the whole series.
“Draco, Draco, you are not a killer.” (Yet…)
“Malfoy, bizarrely, seemed to draw courage and comfort from Dumbledore’s praise…”
Interesting that Dd seemingly not impressed by Malfoy’s revelation that Snape was a double agent “wanting a bit of the action.”
Dd: “I appreciate the difficulty of your position.” Both Katie Bell and Ron almost died as a result of Dd’s considerate inaction. Is this really defensible?”
I don’t really understand what Dd means when he says “no, Draco, it is my mercy, and not yours, that matters now.” Is Dd truly helpless? Against Malfoy? Against Snape? It certainly seems possible that Dd could do a non-verbal spell that would vanquish a mere Malfoy, but that he knows that nothing he can do in his present condition will beat Snape.
“Severus … please …” JKR certainly leaves it open as to exactly what Dd is pleading for. Death, or mercy?
“There was revulsion and hatred etched in the harsh lines of [Snape’s] face” as he prepared to kill Dd. Ok, revulsion and hatred directed at whom? Could still be revulsion at the idea of killing Dd, hatred for either Dd or Voldemort.
“Avada Kevadra!”
And the rest is silence.