Guardian reviewer hates Narnia, Christianity, religion, hateful people

Guardian Unlimited Books | By genre | ‘Narnia represents everything that is most hateful about religion’:

But what’s this? After a long, dark night of the soul and women’s weeping, the lion is suddenly alive again. Why? How?, my children used to ask. Well, it is hard to say why. It does not make any more sense in CS Lewis’s tale than in the gospels. Ah, Aslan explains, it is the “deep magic”, where pure sacrifice alone vanquishes death.

Of all the elements of Christianity, the most repugnant is the notion of the Christ who took our sins upon himself and sacrificed his body in agony to save our souls. Did we ask him to?

Polly Toynbee has written a long, hateful rant expressing her views on what is most hateful about religion. Rather amazing that this hateful, aggressive secularist is spending so much energy hating what she sees as hateful, aggressive relgiion.

Update: I have mixed feelings about the Guardian’s editorial judgment in publishing Toynbee’s piece. On the one hand, that is what newspapers do: publish cogent, provocative opinions that stir up controversy. On the other hand? they should be ashamed of themselves.

Related posts:

• Narnia Tourism Begins
• The case for mocking religion. By Christopher Hitchens
• #67 Amazon Book Reviewer Issues A … Press Release?
• The Book Babes on Chasing the Almighty Dollar: Anne Rice, Harold Bloom, Religion and Bestsellers
• Excellent Guardian profile of the Open Library